Brain Injury, Psychiatry, Faith and Religion

In a new book titled "Religion and Psychiatry: Beyond Boundaries," the author considers why and how, when and where religion (and spirituality) are at stake in the life of psychiatric patients.  The interface between psychiatry and religion is explored at different levels, varying from daily clinical practice to conceptual fieldwork.

Religion is one subject that many people around the world feel extremely passionate about, either feeling strongly in their belief of a certain religion, or being against religions generally or specifically. Other people do not engage with religion at all. These choices represent a part of who we are, and as such it is essential for psychiatrists to understand and be able to relate to their patients' decisions and beliefs in this area.

Religion and Psychiatry is recommended reading for residents in psychiatry, postgraduates in theology, psychology and psychology of religion, researchers in psychiatric epidemiology and trans-cultural psychiatry, as well as professionals in theology, psychiatry and psychology of religion.

Religion (and spirituality) is very much alive and shapes the cultural values and aspirations of psychiatrist and patient alike, as does the choice of not identifying with a particular faith.  Patients bring their beliefs and convictions into the doctor-patient relationship.  The challenge for mental health professionals, whatever their own world view, is to develop and refine their vocabularies such that they truly understand what is communicated to them by their patients.

"The boundary between religious belief and the practice of psychiatry is becoming increasingly porous," say the editors in the Preface to Religion and Psychiatry: Beyond Boundaries. "No longer can psychiatrists in a multi-faith, multi-cultural globalized world hide behind the dismissal of religious belief as pathological, or behind a biomedical scientism, as they are more frequently confronted by distressed patients for whom religious belief may determine their choice of symptoms and their compliance with treatment."

Published on behalf of the World Psychiatric Association, Religion and Psychiatry: Beyond Boundaries, addresses the impact that religion and spirituality have on shaping cultural values, as well as the choice of not identifying with a particular faith. With this book, Peter Verhagen and colleagues provide a framework to understand the importance of these factors in mental well-being, and how to develop and refine their vocabularies to ensure they truly understand what their patients are telling them.

This is the first time that so many psychiatrists, psychologists, and theologians from all parts of the world and from so many different religious and spiritual backgrounds have worked together to produce a book addressing these important issues.

The book discusses what religious traditions can learn from each other to assist the patient, as well as the neurological basis of religious experiences. It describes training programmes that successfully incorporate aspects of religion and demonstrates how different religious and spiritual traditions can be brought together to improve psychiatric training and daily practice.

In the Foreword to Religion and Psychiatry Mario Maj, President of the World Psychiatric Association, states "The WPA welcomes this comprehensive and multifaceted volume, produced by one of its most active Scientific Sectors, hoping that the effort will continue to clarify the issue and stimulate further reflection and research."
 

Revising the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual

I am following the revision process of the DSM-V from my past blog postsThe New York Times published an article about the Revised Diagnostic and Statistical Manual 5th edition which is slated for publication in 2013.  It has been over a decade since the manual was revised. 

These are a few of the changes proposed by doctors charged with revising psychiatry’s encyclopedia of mental disorders, the guidebook that largely determines where society draws the line between normal and not normal, between eccentricity and illness, between self-indulgence and self-destruction — and, by extension, when and how patients should be treated.

Far fewer children would get a diagnosis of bipolar disorder. “Binge eating disorder” and “hypersexuality” might become part of the everyday language. (think sex rehabilitation - Tiger Woods, Charlie Sheen, David Letterman, David Duchovny)  And the way many mental disorders are diagnosed and treated would be sharply revised.

                   

For months they have been the subject of intense speculation and lobbying by advocacy groups, and some proposed changes have already been widely discussed — including folding the diagnosis of Asperger’s syndrome into a broader category, autism spectrum disorder.

But others, including a proposed alternative for bipolar disorder in many children, were recently released. Experts said the recommendations, posted online at DSM5.org for public comment, could bring rapid change in several areas.

The article states:

One significant change would be adding a childhood disorder called temper dysregulation disorder with dysphoria, a recommendation that grew out of recent findings that many wildly aggressive, irritable children who have been given a diagnosis of bipolar disorder do not have it.  Temper dysregulation disorder with dysphoria is a syndrome that in recent years has been labeled childhood bipolar disorder and is actually NOT bipolar disorder. Instead, a new disorder category was created: Temper Dysregulation Disorder with Dysphoria (TDD).

Nestor Lopez-Duran PhD contributes to significant political debate in the media and the blogosphere in his blog

The misdiagnosis led many children to be given powerful antipsychotic drugs, which have serious side effects, including metabolic changes.  Antipsychotic drugs are a class of medicines used to treat psychosis and other mental and emotional conditions.

Some diagnoses of bipolar disorder have been in children as young as 2, and there have been widespread reports that doctors promoting the diagnosis received consulting and speaking fees from the makers of the drugs.

Experts gave the American Psychiatric Association, which publishes the manual, predictably mixed reviews. Some were relieved that the task force working on the manual — which includes neurologists and psychologists as well as psychiatrists — had revised the previous version rather than trying to rewrite it.

Others criticized the authors, saying many diagnoses in the manual would still lack a rigorous scientific basis.

Stanford Law School publishes an interesting blog on the DSM V.

 

The Study Free Will

Have religious leaders and prophets, been able to tap into something science has not?  A recent grant will finance a study on the science of free will.  Are we predestined to live the blueprint of life already created for each of us?  Do we control our own destiny?  Or is it something beyond our comprehension?  Is our free will and control of destiny something foreordained toward a result that we will inevitably reach?

Since the beginning of time, philosophers, scientists and theologians have sought to find out whether human beings have free will or whether other forces are at work to control our actions, decisions and choices.

Now, Florida State University philosopher Alfred Mele has been awarded a $4.4 million grant from the John Templeton Foundation to get to the bottom of this question for the ages. Mele, the William H. and Lucyle Werkmeister Professor of Philosophy, will oversee a four-year project to improve understanding of free will in philosophy, religion and science. 

The primary purpose of the project is to improve understanding of free will in three spheres: science (especially neuroscience and social psychology); philosophy; and theology.  The project's website can be accessed here.

I previously posted in this blog about the new revelations of free will.  In fact, in 2008, Professor John-Dylan Haynes and colleagues at the Max Planck Institute in Germany reported findings of an extraordinary experiment which seems to show that 'free will' -- the most cherished tenet of humanity, which decrees that Man has total control of his own actions -- may, in fact, be little more than an illusion.

I read the book entitled Neurophilosophy of Free Will by Henrik Walter and Cynthia Klohr.  This among my many other self-study texts in theology, science and psychology posits questions including:  Do we control our own future or are the choices we end up making set in place in advance?

 
 
 

 

Neuroscientists routinely investigate such classical philosophical topics as consciousness, thought, language, meaning, aesthetics, and death. According to Henrik Walter, philosophers should in turn embrace the wealth of research findings and ideas provided by neuroscience. In this book Walter applies the methodology of neurophilosophy to one of philosophy's central challenges, the notion of free will. Neurophilosophical conclusions are based on, and consistent with, scientific knowledge about the brain and its functioning.

Walter's answer to whether there is free will is, It depends. The basic questions concerning free will are (1) whether we are able to choose other than we actually do, (2) whether our choices are made intelligibly, and (3) whether we are really the originators of our choices. According to Walter, freedom of will is an illusion if we mean by it that under identical conditions we would be able to do or decide otherwise, while simultaneously acting only for reasons and being the true originators of our actions. In place of this scientifically untenable strong version of free will, Walter offers what he calls natural autonomy--self-determination unaided by supernatural powers that could exist even in an entirely determined universe. Although natural autonomy can support neither our traditional concept of guilt nor certain cherished illusions about ourselves, it does not imply the abandonment of all concepts of responsibility. For we are not mere marionettes, with no influence over our thoughts or actions.

It will be interesting to see how Dr. Mele's project adds to this conversation.


 

Continuing DSM Revisions

My ongoing investigation into the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual, anticipated 2013 release, reveals the following sources:

NPR: "Doctors use the DSM to diagnose patients, and insurance companies use it to decide on reimbursement, so it's incredibly important in the profession of psychiatry."

NPR reports on a change for children currently being diagnosed with bipolar disorder (also known as manic-depression): "The condition will be called temper dysregulation disorder, and it will be seen as a brain or biological dysfunction, but not as a necessarily lifelong condition like bipolar. ... By adding this new entry, the American Psychiatric Association is trying to use the considerable institutional power of the DSM to curb use of the pediatric bipolar label" (Spiegel, 2/10).

The Associated Press: The American Psychiatric Association "is seeking feedback via the Internet from both psychiatrists and the general public about whether the changes will be helpful before finalizing them. ... Sure to generate debate, the draft also proposes diagnosing people as being at high risk of developing some serious mental disorders -- such as dementia or schizophrenia -- based on early symptoms, even though there's no way to know who will worsen into full-blown illness" (Neergaard, 2/10).

USA Today reports on efforts to classify illness like autism as broader illnesses rather than a specific subtype: "DSM-5 proposes replacing diagnoses for autism, Asperger's, childhood disintegrative and pervasive developmental disorders with a single diagnosis, 'autism spectrum disorders,' based on deficits in social interaction and communication and the presence of repetitive behaviors and interests" (Rubin, 2/9).

To follow my other posts on proposed changes to DSM see http://brainandspine.titololawoffice.com/2010/02/articles/brain-injury-news/revising-the-diagnostic-and-statistical-manual/

http://brainandspine.titololawoffice.com/2010/02/articles/brain-injury-news/revising-the-diagnostic-and-statistical-manual/

http://brainandspine.titololawoffice.com/2010/02/articles/brain-injury-news/revising-the-diagnostic-and-statistical-manual/

http://brainandspine.titololawoffice.com/2010/02/articles/brain-injury-news/revising-the-diagnostic-and-statistical-manual/

Social Security to Add Early Onset Alzheimer's Benefit

All to often people who suffer from disease are unable to get care due to insurance company limitations and policies, lack of insurance or finances to cover expenses.  Sometimes folks are left with Social Security Benefit applications for their care.

In its effort to improve and expedite the disability determination process, the Social Security Administration (SSA) has announced that it will add early-onset Alzheimer's disease to its Compassionate Allowances Initiative. The initiative identifies debilitating diseases and medical conditions that meet the SSA's disability standards for Social Security Disability Income (SSDI) or Supplemental Security Income (SSI). 

Social Security is launching this expedited decision process with a total of 50 conditions.  Over time, more diseases and conditions will be added.  A list of the first 50 impairments -- 25 rare diseases and 25 cancers -- can be found at www.socialsecurity.gov/compassionateallowances.

This recent development will lead to increased care more quickly for those who could not otherwise afford it.

Since 2003, the Alzheimer's Association has been advocating on behalf of individuals with early-onset Alzheimer's as they navigate the Social Security disability determinations process and welcomes the SSA's decision. Until now, individuals with early-onset Alzheimer's disease have faced a myriad of challenges when applying for SSDI or SSI, including a long decision process, initial denials, and multiple appeals.

Today's decision will simplify and streamline the SSDI/SSI application process and decrease the wait time for benefits, which for some has lasted as long as three years. There are currently an estimated 5.3 million Americans with Alzheimer's disease. Although the majority of Alzheimer cases are individuals age 65 and older, a significant number of people under age 65 are also affected by this fatal disease and have few financial options other than the Social Security disability program. 

This good news comes at a time when politics has brought the issue of universal health care to a stand still.  It always intrigues me that certain folks think the "right" to choose a doctor, hence stumping public/social or universal health care, exists.  While, at the same time, those folks shun the idea that anyone has a "right" to not be subject to Rendition based on suspicion, or the "right" of due process.

What ever your reflection on the matter, the recent Compassionate Allowances Initiative moves us in the right direction.
 

New Website Designed to Help with Mental Illness

I came across a new website directed at assisting with mental illness. Step Up on Second.

Step Up on Second announces the launch of its newly enhanced Web 2.0 site. Step Up on Second is a California non-profit organization providing support services for adults affected by severe and persistent mental illness, and young adults experiencing the initial symptoms of a mental illness and their families.

The interactive site provides resources for loved ones, clients, and family members in search of an organization that can provide help, hope, and a home to individuals affected by mental illness.

Step Up on Second provides help through comprehensive, integrated clinical programs for relapse prevention; hope through the embrace of community, opportunities for inclusion, advocacy, and empowerment; and permanent supportive home units for stability achieving self-determined goals.

Recently Actress Glenn Close posted on their blog.

Comment on Understanding Depression

 Daniel responds to my post on Understanding Depression at http://brainandspine.titololawoffice.com/2009/11/articles/psychiartric-psychological-iss/understanding-depression/

I appreciate the support because depression almost always results in traumatic brain injury cases I handle.  Not to mention the clinical nature of the disorder in non-traumatic brain injury cases.

Thanks for this interesting article. I think it is very important to talk about this topic, because it becomes more and more up to date. Lots of people are adversely affected by depression without knowing it. And this is very dangerous because of the consequences of not treating this suffering.

 

Phobia Fear

Reader Carol Brown wrote me recently from her nursing perspective.  I am afraid there are more phobias than I anticipated.  (wait - that fear is a phobia and probably has a name too!)  Carol writes about phobias that nurses are not privy to in their training but confront in practice. 

If you are into phobias or are worried you have some (which worry may be sign of phobia) read Carol's article by clicking

http://www.nursingdegreeguide.org/2010/100-weird-phobias-that-really-exist/comment-page-1/#comment-5607

Antidepressants

Recall the recent post I made raising the issue of whether antidepressants were properly relied on by patients and physicians.  That post can be accessed here. http://brainandspine.titololawoffice.com/2009/12/articles/psychiartric-psychological-iss/antidepressant-may-change-personality/

 A new study appears in the December issue of The Annals of Pharmacotherapy.  (Published Online, November 24, 2009. www.theannals.com, DOI 10.1345/aph.1M326) Suicidal adolescents who were prescribed an antidepressant medication during inpatient psychiatric hospital treatment were 85 percent less likely than others to be readmitted within a month after discharge.

The results provide additional evidence that antidepressants may play a key role in helping improve the mental health of suicidal youth. Cynthia Fontanella, co-author of the study and assistant professor of social work at Ohio State University, points out that the the findings are especially important now, because antidepressant use dropped in 2003 after the Food and Drug Administration issued a black box warning that some antidepressants may increase the risk of suicidal behavior for pediatric patients. A black-box warning is the most serious type of warning in prescription drug labeling.

Despite considerable recent attention and wide-scale interventionsby regulatory authorities that have changed drug usage patterns,the possible relationship between psychotropic pharmacotherapy and suicidal behavior among children and adolescents remainsunclear. Confounding by diagnosis adds to confusion in the interpretationof the relationship between antidepressant use and suicidal behavior among young people. Cynthia Fontanella's recent research suggests that antidepressants may be protective against early readmission after hospitalization for suicide attempts or ideation, but that psychotropic polypharmacy (although common) may be associated with increased risk of rehospitalization.There remains an urgent need for high-quality, ongoing research into these clinical dilemmas.

Once again, I invite your input and thoughts on this issue by posting a comment.
 

DSM-5 Publication Date Moved Back

The American Psychiatric Association revised the timeline for publishing the fifth edition of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, moving the anticipated release date to May 2013.

The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM) is the standard classification of mental disorders used by mental health professionals in the United States. It is intended to be applicable in a wide array of contexts and used by clinicians and researchers of many different orientations (e.g., biological, psychodynamic, cognitive, behavioral, interpersonal, family/systems).

The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fourth Edition (DSM-IV) has been designed for use across clinical settings (inpatient, outpatient, partial hospital, consultation-liaison, clinic, private practice, and primary care), with community populations. It can be used by a wide range of health and mental health professionals, including psychiatrists and other physicians, psychologists, social workers, nurses, occupational and rehabilitation therapists, and counselors. It is also a necessary tool for collecting and communicating accurate public health statistics.

Diagnostic criteria provide a common language for clinical communication and their use has been shown to increase diagnostic agreement between clinicians.   It is important to understand that the appropriate use of the diagnostic criteria requires clinical training and that they cannot be simply applied in a cookbook fashion.

Another important aspect of the DSM diagnostic system is that the diagnoses are described strictly in terms of patterns of symptoms that tend to cluster together.  These symptoms can be observed by the clinician or reported by the patient or family members.  Because it focuses on manifest symptoms clinicians from widely differing theoretical orientations can therefore use the DSM.  Since the causes of most mental disorders are subject to ongoing scientific inquiry, the DSM avoids incorporating competing theories in its diagnostic definitions.  This feature has been an important element in the widespread clinical acceptance of the DSM, and has allowed a wide scope of research investigation.  

This is also an important limitation of the DSM system.   Patients sharing the same diagnostic label do not necessarily have disturbances that share the same etiology nor would they necessarily respond to the same treatment.   It is therefore critical to understand that the diagnostic terms and categories in the DSM represent only current knowledge about how symptoms cluster together.   

I find that the DSM has been too general in situations involving my clients and too specific and exclusionary in other situations.  I, and experts I consuted, fully expect that, over the coming decades, the DSM system will be radically reorganized as the etiologies of mental disorders become better understood.

 

Employee Pay Structure and Parties Improve Performance

So is your boss paying you enough?  Do you want a raise or better working conditions?  What motivates employees to perform?

People paid by the hour exhibit a stronger relationship between income and happiness, according to a study published in the current issue of Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin (PSPB), the official journal of the Society for Personality and Social Psychology

The Society for Personality and Social Psychology (SPSP) is an academic society for personality and social psychologists with over 4500 members worldwide. SPSP serves as Division 8 of the American Psychological Association and publishes the journals Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin and Personality and Social Psychology Review and the biannual newsletter, Dialogue. It also co-publishes the journal Social and Personality and Psychology Science.

Researchers explored the relationship between income and happiness by focusing on the organizational arrangements that make the connection between time and money. They found that the way in which an employee is paid is tied to their feeling of happiness.

The researchers theorize that hourly wage-earners focus more attention on their pay than those who earn a salary.

A UK survey of managers across health and social care found that nearly two thirds (62 per cent) of them believe that Christmas parties are important in helping improve employee engagement. The survey comes in the wake of a government report that blames UK business leaders for low levels of staff engagement.
 

Anti-Depressant may change Personality

Have you ever considered the claims by celebrities, like Tom Cruise, or health care professionals that decry the impact of anti-psychotics and anti-depression medicine?  Have we come to rely on Prozac, Paxil and the laundry list of "feel good" medication to overcome what generations of folks have dealt with without them?  Or, is there a benefit reaped by those on the medication?  Do doctors overprescribe?  I am interested to know what you think.  Drop me a comment. 

The December issue of Archives of General Psychiatry, one of the JAMA/Archives journals reports Individuals taking a medication to treat depression may experience changes in their personality separate from the alleviation of depressive symptoms.

Two personality traits, neuroticism and extraversion, have been related to depression risk, according to background information in the article. Individuals who are neurotic tend to experience negative emotions and emotional instability, whereas extraversion refers not only to socially outgoing behavior but also to dominance and a tendency to experience positive emotions. Both traits have been linked to the brain's serotonin system, which is also targeted by the class of antidepressants known as selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs).

Read More Arch Gen Psychiatry.2009;66[12]:1322-1330.  Drop me a comment on your take on this issue.



 

Holiday Stress

The American Psychological Association notes that Holiday stress is a leading cause of financial stress for Americans.   National unemployment levels push into double digits for the first time in decades, the American Psychological Association's (APA) newest Stress in America survey finds that Americans continue to cite financial concerns as leading sources of stress.

Approximately seven in ten Americans report that money is a significant source of stress (71 percent), according to APA's 2009 Stress in America survey, with similarly high percentages reporting stress resulting from work (69 percent) and the economy (63 percent). More than half of adults (55 percent) also cited family responsibilities as a significant source of stress in their lives.

APA suggests the following strategies to manage holiday stress and enjoy the season:

1. Take time for yourself. Taking care of yourself helps you to take better care of others in your life. Go for a long walk or take time out to read or listen to your favorite music. By slowing down you will actually have more energy to accomplish your goals.

2. Volunteer. Many charitable organizations face new challenges as a result of the ongoing economic downturn. Find a local charity, such as a soup kitchen or a shelter, where you and your family can volunteer together. Helping others who are less fortunate can put hardships in perspective and can build stronger family relationships.

3. Set realistic expectations. No holiday celebration is perfect; view inevitable missteps as opportunities to demonstrate flexibility and resilience. Create a realistic budget and remind your children that the holidays aren't about expensive gifts.

4. Remember what's important. Commercialism can overshadow the true sentiment of the holiday season. When your holiday expense list is running longer than your monthly budget, scale back. Remind yourself that family, friends and the relationships in our lives are what matter most.

5. Seek support. Talk about stress related to the holidays with your friends and family. Getting things out in the open can help you navigate your feelings and work toward a solution. If you continue to feel overwhelmed, consider talking with a professional such as a psychologist to help you develop coping strategies and better manage your stress. A psychologist has the skills and professional training to help people learn to manage stress and cope more effectively with life problems, using techniques based on best available research and their clinical skills and experience, and taking into account an individual's unique values, goals and circumstances. Psychologists have doctoral degrees and are licensed by the state in which they practice. They receive one of the highest levels of education of all health care professionals, spending an average of seven years in education and training after they receive their undergraduate degrees.

Read more here.

Depression after Stroke

A new finding appears in Psychosomatics, the official journal of the Academy of Psychosomatic Medicine which publishes peer-reviewed research and clinical experiences in the practice of psychosomatic medicine/consultation-liaison psychiatry.

Poynter B, et al. Sex differences in the prevalence of post-stroke depression: a systematic review. Psychosomatics 50(6), 2009, find:

Depression occurs in as many as one-third of patients after a stroke, and women are at somewhat higher risk, according to a large new review of studies. Post-stroke depression is associated with greater disability, reduced quality of life and an increased risk of death.

The systematic review appears in the November-December issue of the journal Psychosomatics.
 

Understanding Depression

Americans do not believe they know much about depression , but are highly aware of the risks of not receiving care, according to a survey released today by the National Alliance on Mental Illness (NAMI).

See full survey results at http://www.nami.org/depression.

The survey provides a "three dimensional" measurement of responses from members of the general public who do not know anyone with depression, caregivers of adults diagnosed with depression and adults actually living with the illness.

- Seventy-one percent of the public sample said they are not familiar with depression, but 68 percent or more know specific consequences that can come from not receiving treatment-including suicide (84 percent).

- Sixty-two percent believe they know some symptoms of depression, but 39 percent said they do not know many or any at all.

- One major finding: almost 50 percent of caregivers who responded had been diagnosed with depression themselves, but only about 25 percent said they were engaged in treatment.

- Almost 60 percent of people living with depression reported that they rely on their primary care physicians rather than mental health professionals for treatment. Medication and "talk therapy" are primary treatments-if a person can get them-but other options are helpful.

- Fifteen percent of people living with depression use animal therapy with 54 percent finding it to be "extremely" or "quite a bit" helpful. Those using prayer and physical exercise also ranked them high in helpfulness (47 percent and 40 percent respectively).

- When people living with depression discontinue medication or talk therapy, cost is a common reason, but other significant factors include a desire "to make it on my own," whether they believe the treatment is actually working and in the case of medication, side effects.

"The survey reveals gaps and guideposts on roads to recovery," said NAMI Executive Director Michael J. Fitzpatrick. "It tells what has been found helpful in treating depression. It can help caregivers better anticipate stress that will confront them. It reflects issues that need to be part of ongoing health care reform."
 

Good Diet - Less Depression

The British Journal of Psychiatry,  available online, published findings that good diet contributes to less depression.

A new study led by researchers in the UK found that an overall healthy "whole food" diet comprising a high proportion of fruits, vegetables and fish, protected middle aged people against depression compared to a processed food diet containing a high proportion of high fat dairy food, processed meat, fried food, refined grains and sugar-laden desserts.

 Read More Here.

Women Beat Men

Women come in first again!  This time it's officially scientific:

Women are better than men at distinguishing between emotions, especially fear and disgust, according to a new study published in the online version of the journal Neuropsychologia....

While women have long been thought to outperform men in neuropsychological tests, until now, these findings were inconsistent. To obtain more conclusive evidence, the Université de Montréal researchers did not use photographs to analyze the reaction of subjects. Instead, the scientists hired actors and actresses to simulate fear and disgust. "Facial movements have been shown to play an important role in the perception of an emotion's intensity as well as stimulate different parts of the brain used in the treatment of such information," says Collignon, who also works as a researcher at the Université catholique de Louvain's Institute of Neuroscience in Belgium.

Read More.